Bayfield, Colorado Houses for Sale


Home Prices

AVERAGE
925,421 -25%
MEDIAN
674,900 -7%

Relative Price (per sqft.)

PRICE

Listings

ACTIVE
19 0%
NEW
24 +50%

Market Duration

DAYS
38 -62%

Crime & Safety

Police Officers 8  
Police Civilians 1  
Total Arrests 5 (2020)
Total Incidents 57 (2020)
CrimeScore 11.83  
National Rank 1306th  
Statewide Rank 30th  

Local Statistics

Population 2,586 (0.00%)
House Size (sqft.) 2,638 (7.08%)

Criminal Offenses

Animal Cruelty 1
Assault Offenses 3
Burglary/Breaking & Entering 7
Destruction/Damage/Vandalism of Property 7
Fraud Offenses 14
Larceny/Theft Offenses 23
Motor Vehicle Theft 4

Tour these homes now!

Call 1-855-440-1362
to get connected

Photo by Ralph Kelly on Unsplash
0
 

$199,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

223 Tucker Lane
Bayfield, CO 81122

4.0 Bedrooms

2.0 Bathrooms

1,280 sqft

1,306 Safety Rank

Sue R Plvan, R1 Colorado, C: 970-426-8066, plvansue@gmail.com, buyselldurangohomes.com: This is a ONE HALF Ownership on Vallecito Creek! Short term rentals allowed! This 4 bedroom/2 bath charming cabin sits on a half an acre of prime river waterfront north of the lake. The two owners have used it and rented it out for many years and have put together a two month on/two month off use arrangement which has worked well. Fully furnished, this is the perfect getaway as well as investment. Enjoy the wonderful deck and outdoor space on the creek! Fully stocked kitchen with microwave, refrigerator, stove/oven. Washer/dryer are in mud room area which adds an additional 120 square feet to the cabin. Home is not winterized but easily could be upgraded. New septic system has been installed Fall of 2021.

0
 

$299,900

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

285 W Grimes Creek Drive
Bayfield, CO 81122

1.0 Bedrooms

1.0 Bathrooms

396 sqft

1,306 Safety Rank

Justin D Osborn, The Wells Group of Durango, Inc., O: 970-946-3935, justin@wellsgroupdurango.com, http://southwestcoloradoranchbrokers.com/: One level park model on a permanent foundation with year round creek frontage. Located on the confluence of West Grimes Creek & East Grimes Creek, this parcel goes across the creek and encompasses approximately 2,000 sq ft of an island! Huge, covered wrap around porch goes around the entire cabin and provides plenty of space for outdoor entertainment or for simply relaxing and listening to the water. There's an additional bunkhouse with electric that provides overflow sleeping quarters. Low taxes at only $410.08 a year. Shared water well (located on subject property) with neighbor is recorded at 15 gallons perm minute! Annual fee for the water well to Pine River Irrigation District is $273.70 split amongst both parcels. Located at 7800' elevation with good year round access. Exceptional recreational opportunities are right out the door including both lake and stream fishing, hiking, backpacking, cross country skiing, and fabulous big game hunting for elk, moose, bighorn sheep, mountain goat, and mule deer. The Weminuche Wilderness, the largest wilderness area in Colorado at 499,771 acres, has multiple trailheads located just up the road.

0
 

$325,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

18687 County Road 501
Bayfield, CO 81122

2.0 Bedrooms

1.0 Bathrooms

624 sqft

1,306 Safety Rank

Ashley Blackmore, Blackmore Group, O: 970-444-2431, ashley@ashleyblackmorehomes.com, www.crenmls.com: Cabin with creek running thru your yard. Your chance to own a piece of paradise located in Colorado at Vallecito Lake. Enjoy the sound and view from your covered deck of Grimes Creek. Enjoy all the mountains and lake have to offer. The community offers hiking, biking, boating, fishing, hunting, its an outdoor paradise.

0
 

$349,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

18681 County Road 501 #501
Bayfield, CO 81122

2.0 Bedrooms

1.0 Bathrooms

649 sqft

1,306 Safety Rank

Ashley Blackmore, Blackmore Group, O: 970-444-2431, ashley@ashleyblackmorehomes.com, www.crenmls.com: Cabin with creek running thru your yard and views of the lake and mountains. Your chance to own a piece of paradise located in Colorado at Vallecito Lake. Enjoy the sound and view from your covered deck of Grimes Creek. Enjoy all the mountains and lake have to offer. The community offers hiking, biking, boating, fishing, hunting, it's an outdoor paradise.

0
 

$360,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

920 Bayfield Parkway
Bayfield, CO 81122

3.0 Bedrooms

2.0 Bathrooms

1,666 sqft

1,306 Safety Rank

Mary M Rigby, RE/MAX Pinnacle, C: 970-946-4975, maryrigby@remax.net, http://www.homesindurango.com: Charming country home nestled on 1.18 acres with fantastic mountain views. There is a spacious patio/deck which is perfect for outdoor dining and entertaining or for just relaxing and enjoying the peace and quiet. If you like gardening this is a great property with plenty of room for flower gardens and vegetable gardens. The spacious family room has plenty of windows providing an abundance of natural light and a built in bookcase. There are hardwood floors throughout that were refinished in 2012. The farm style country kitchen has a breakfast bar and a cozy wood stove to take the chill off the cool evenings. There are 3 bedrooms and 2 baths. The unfinished basement provides a great area for extra storage. The windows were replaced in 2012. This home adjoins property owned by the Town of Bayfield so it is very private. Easy access to the Pine River (Los Pinos River). The fenced yard is great for kids and pets. There is also a storage building on the property. Don't miss this opportunity to own a country cottage with easy access to the Pine River, the town park and to shopping. Seller is offering an $11,000 updating allowance with an acceptable contract.

Tour these homes now!

Call 1-855-440-1362
to get connected

Photo by Ralph Kelly on Unsplash
0
 

$365,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

811 E Sage Street
Bayfield, CO 81122

3.0 Bedrooms

2.0 Bathrooms

1,092 sqft

1,306 Safety Rank

Victoria Hamstra, Bayfield Realty, C: 602-370-8603, victoria@bayfieldrealty.com, www.crenmls.com: Welcome home! This home is move-in ready and located on a quiet cul-de-sac, walking distance to Bayfield High School and Bayfield Middle School. Enjoy a home that has been well cared for and updated. Updates include: mini-split AC/Heat unit, exterior paint, half bathroom, large retaining wall, and more! Attached garage ready for your home gym or keeping your car out of the snow. Low maintenance backyard and beautiful views from the back of your lot. Perfectly sized three rooms with a master half bath installed in 2021. Schedule your showing today and start living in this beautiful in-town Bayfield home.

0
 

$375,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

231 Mill St.
Bayfield, CO 81122

4.0 Bedrooms

2.0 Bathrooms

1,980 sqft

1,306 Safety Rank

Phil Schoon, Keller Williams Realty Southwest Associates, LLC, C: 970-769-2857, pschoon@kw.com, www.crenmls.com: 231 Mill St. located in the heart of old town Bayfield, just off the historic Mill Street district. This property is in walking distance to restaurants, shops, parks, schools, town hall, and the beautiful Pine River. The home, which needs some tender, loving, care, was built in 1899, and is surrounded by mature landscaping that includes tall pines and apple trees. 231 Mill St. has performed as a rental property for the better part of the last 20 years, and could very well remain as such. Alternative uses could be a fix and flip, or this home could be a charming primary residence. Prospective buyers are encourage to call the listing agent to gain more insight to the current lease situation, condition of home, and potential future uses for 231 Mill St. *Note: More pictures to come 5/23/2022

0
 

$445,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

1723 Taylor Circle
Bayfield, CO 81122

3.0 Bedrooms

2.0 Bathrooms

1,412 sqft

1,306 Safety Rank

Lauren Ammerman, The Wells Group of Durango, Inc., C: 970-903-1333, lauren@wellsgroupdurango.com, www.laurenammerman.com: Immaculately maintained and well designed in-town Bayfield home, offers plenty of fenced yard space on a perimeter Dove Ranch lot, and lives large all on one level. Open concept living, dining, and kitchen featuring farmhouse grey toned laminate flooring, lots of natural light throughout, tongue and groove vaulted ceilings, and a welcoming space to entertain. The kitchen features beautiful hickory cabinets, newly tiled backsplash, neutral colored tile flooring, and new GE black stainless appliances. New light fixtures throughout and crisp paint colors finish off the warm space. Primary bedroom is roomy and bright with an adjacent bathroom with two vanities, large walk-in closet with built-ins. Across the home are the two spacious guest bedrooms, clean and bright, and share a nice hall bath. Spotless laundry room space with a perfect location just inside the two-car garage. Outside you’ll find a large, fenced yard with beautiful groomed green grass, in ground automated sprinkler system, nicely landscaped. Backing up to the church to the north makes the lot live large, but also offers a place to roam, play basketball, kick a soccer ball, or just enjoy the views to the north. Home features energy efficient furnace and offers A/C for the summer afternoons. This home is ready to move into, clean and polished, easy maintenance stucco, it won’t last long at this price and perfection.

0
 

$462,500

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

459 Sage Crest Way
Bayfield, CO 81122

3.0 Bedrooms

2.0 Bathrooms

1,752 sqft

1,306 Safety Rank

Isaac Fleener, Bayfield Realty, C: 970-759-9353, isaac@bayfieldrealty.com, www.BayfieldRealty.com: Great home on just over 3 acres conveniently located between Durango and Bayfield off of County Road 510 in Bayfield ISD. The house features 1751 SF with three large bedrooms and two full baths on a permanent foundation. The split floor plan has large master suite with walk-in closet and great views to the north. The living room (with wood burning stove), kitchen and dining area flow seamlessly together creating a great living space that everyone is sure to enjoy. Off of the kitchen is a large mud room with washer and dryer. A second full bath and two additional bedrooms complete this great layout. The large covered deck provides great shade and outstanding views of the San Juan Mountains leading out to a fenced yard for the kids or animals. Other features on the property include a small shed and two carports. The home is served by La Plata Archuleta Water for household use and a well for lawn watering and livestock! Come and see this great property and call La Plata County Home.

0
 

$495,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

212 County Road 500
Bayfield, CO 81122

8.0 Bedrooms

5.0 Bathrooms

2,273 sqft

1,306 Safety Rank

Ashley Blackmore, Blackmore Group, O: 970-444-2431, ashley@ashleyblackmorehomes.com, www.crenmls.com: Huge opportunity. All offers due by May 10,2022. A great investment property to use as a rental, ARBNB, or live and rent opportunity with this tri-level multi living home duplex with 5 Br 3 Baths on the upper level and 3 Br 2 Bathson the lower level. Currently the lower level has a long-term renter that rents for $1150 Plus $150 per month for Utilities in the Summer and $250 for thewinter months and has rented for over 3.5 years. Upstairs is also rented and the entire property generates $3,150.00 as of March 2022. The upper level has two levels of living with plenty of room for a person who wants to live and rent the bottom. Although an original cabin is from 1955 this home has been extensively remodeled, updated, and added on to throughout the years with a massive full remodel approx. 28 years ago. All appliances are around 3 years old and are included. Once used for a large ranch employee housing, the home has now been converted into a rental. The upper living space has brand new carpeting and turnkey and the current lowest level renter helps you get a return on your investment the moment you sign the papers and transfer the lease. The Tenants pay the rent timely, this overall combination makes this property easy to manage. The owner states that the property also comes with a large bonus and that bonus consists of the 2.6 acres of land that hasCentral Sewer running through the far eastern portion of the Property and that plus access to Central Water Service allows this property to possibly have a future subdivision approved for a total of Five 1/2 acre lots, a 5 Lot Subdivision would be much easier to accomplish. An actual subdivision plan was previously drawn up and recorded, the property was also surveyed inconnection with the proposed subdivision many years ago. In fact, the subdivision plan still shows up on the Title for anyone to see. That plan was never submitted or followed up by anyone. As a result, the Subdivisionhas not been approved by the County as a subdivision, but if a person wants to take the time effort and money to go through the approval process creating the 1/2 lots they can. There is a small Creek that runs water in the late Spring and Summer that is an irrigation ditch that runs through the property and there is some lower-level area can be used to create a small pondThis area is one of America’s Best Kept Secrets and only 20 Miles to Durango, Colorado, A myriad of outdoor activities are available, Downhill Skiing, Snowmobiling, Cross Country Skiing, Mesa Verde Indian Ruins, HistoricalDurango/Silverton Steam Train, White Water Rafting, Fishing, Water Skiing, Mountain Wilderness Hiking, Horse Back Riding, Mountain & Road Biking, Hunting, Overnight Pack Trips into the High Country plus thearea has Deer, Elk, Big Horn Sheep, Ducks, Geese, Bald Eagles, Osprey. Grouse and more. The area’s Bayfield School District is also highly rated but there is open enrollment for La Plata County. Current income $3150 monthly. You can make quite a large return on these 2 acres!

Tour these homes now!

Call 1-855-440-1362
to get connected

Photo by Ralph Kelly on Unsplash