Angelica, New York Houses for Sale

Angelica, NY Prices for Houses for Sale

85,900 -37%
85,900 -59%

Relative Price (per sqft.)


Listings of Angelica Homes for Purchase

1 -50%

Market Duration of Homes Sold

29 -95%

Local Statistics

Population 809 (-0.01%)
House Size (sqft.) 1,500 (-66.19%)


Residential / Single Family Residence

Days on Market: 133

8866 Holdridge Road
Angelica, NY 14709

1.0 Bedrooms

1.0 Bathrooms

1,140 sqft

Cozy up next to the fire in this year round log home with a full basement surrounded by breathtaking views. This home would be great as a hunting lodge, a great get-away, or your very own log home! The location couldn't be better with the Guilles State Forest with 2,300 acres to hike, snowmobile or hunt on close by.



Residential / Single Family Residence

Days on Market: 123

19 Mechanic Street
Angelica, NY 14709

3.0 Bedrooms

2.0 Bathrooms

1,576 sqft

Your Opportunity to own this MOVE-IN READY 3 Bedroom, 1.5 Bath, Colonial with Storybook Curb Appeal, Detached garage is 4 CAR Deep w/workshop. Situated on deep/wide park-like village lot. Upgrades include new windows, electrical throughout, newer bathroom fixtures & flooring, 2 car oversized front garage added in 2017, blacktop & cement driveway extension, composite graduated back steps w/safety railings, new built in dishwasher & hot water heater. The charming features throughout this lovely home speak quality & timeless elegance. Hardwood flooring, high ceilings, carved wood staircase, bonus walk-in closet in the primary bedroom, sunporch w/ enclosed laundry closet, spacious kitchen features a gas cook top island, wall oven & super storage cupboard space, plus an eat-in nook! Last but not least located in a village where history lives!



Residential / Single Family Residence

Days on Market: 195

5524 Fleming Rd
Angelica, NY 14709

4.0 Bedrooms

2.0 Bathrooms

2,332 sqft

We are pleased to present a beautiful verdant 82+/- acre family farm that boasts the very best of farm charm and the country living lifestyle. Immaculately maintained, and constructed with a style of home from golden years, the high ceilings, large rooms, wood floors and views from every window, this 1870 four-bedroom farmhouse is a wonderful sanctuary to call home, drink Ice tea on the veranda and enjoy the breeze and view. The Farmhouse is nested privately 200 yards down a town-maintained dead end dirt road 2 miles west of the historic village of Angelica, named for Angelica Schuyler Church ("sister in law of Alexander Hamilton") whose family once owned all of Allegany County. The terraced well-drained land includes beautiful hardwoods and 28 tillable acres of which 14 are NOFA Certified Organic. Corn, Soybeans,Tartary buckwheat, hay and pasture are all tillable producers here over the years. Additionally, approximately a half a mile of Angelica Creek meanders through the property connecting to the Genesee river. The Italianate house was built in 1870 with 12 foot high Living room ceilings, tall low Living room windows, original plank floors and heavy trim and moldings throughout. The large country kitchen is complemented with a family dining room, and spacious laundry room/mudroom, a full bathroom and a breezy relaxing screened in porch. Upstairs you will find four 4 bedrooms, an office and a full bath. The home is surrounded by mature plantings, flower beds, established raspberry patch and asparagus beds. In the back yard, there is a private above ground pool and deck overlooking the fenced organic garden, and a play set for the smallest family members. For farming activity, there are 3 machinery sheds, and a large well-maintained barn with attached tennis backboard court. The property also includes a commercial kitchen with attached 1/2 bath, and a refreshing outdoor shower. There are two additional septic systems both with electricity and water for possible guest quarters. There is an additional sister property with acreage for sale connected to the farm with a successful Airbnb business operating on it called the "Angelica Granary" if you want a more space or a business. If you are searching for that perfect farm life, or want to move to a historic part of Allegany county and enjoy a property with all of the elements of nature, scenery, peace and quiet, this property is it! Priced well to sell, check this one out. Dimensions: Kitchen 28'6 x 9'6 Dining 17'5 x 15' Living Room 24'5 x 15' Bathroom lower '3 x 5'7 Screened porch 12'7 x 11'7 Laundry/mudroom 14'6 x 9'5 Foyer/entry 7'x 5' Bedroom 1 16' x '7 Bedroom 2 12'7 x 9'5 Bedroom 3 9'7 x 5'8 Bedroom 4 15' x 12'5 Office 10'7 x 11' -1870 farmhouse -Pool -Dead end road -Barn -Outbuildings -Commercial kitchen -1/2 mile frontage Angelica creek -Organic Tillable acres-Tartary buckwheat -Deer hunting -1541' road frontage -GMO' convey -Taxes TBD -Genesee Valley Schools -Sold AS IS

Featured Angelica Brokers