Monticello, Wisconsin Houses for Sale

Home Prices

403,167 +64%
400,000 +63%

Relative Price (per sqft.)



2 +100%

Market Duration

99 +19,600%

Crime & Safety

Police Officers 3  
Police Civilians 0  
Total Incidents 10 (2020)
CrimeScore 1.52  
National Rank 155th  
Statewide Rank 2nd  

Local Statistics

Population 1,185 (-0.01%)
House Size (sqft.) 2,148 (23.41%)

Criminal Offenses

Drug/Narcotic Offenses 8
Larceny/Theft Offenses 2

Tour these homes now!

Call 1-855-440-1362
to get connected

Photo by Ralph Kelly on Unsplash


Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

N6256 Cemetery Rd
Monticello, WI 53570

4.0 Bedrooms

4.0 Bathrooms

3,458 sqft

155 Safety Rank

Picture perfect home. From stunning views, spotless home, to a cozy home feeling this is perfect for you! Immaculate home from floor to ceiling. Walk in to tall ceilings, lots of windows, & an open spacious feeling. Main level has your living room and family room with a beautiful staircase going upstairs in the middle. The kitchen has a large island and tons of cabinets. Formal dining room for those fancy dinners. Upstairs you will find a large primary suite with a newly remodeled bath. 3 more bedrooms and another recently remodeled full bath and a large closet in the hallway. Basement is partially finished with a large rec room. Soak in the acreage around you sitting in your screened in back deck! Additional outdoor deck wraps around that! Mud room has laundry.



Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

W4031 County Highway C
Monticello, WI 53570

3.0 Bedrooms

3.0 Bathrooms

2,352 sqft

155 Safety Rank

Incredible views from this one of a kind custom build ranch home on 5+ acres! The open concept plan features 9' ceilings, plaster walls, kitchen island w seating, split bedroom floor plan, exraordinary master ensuite, as well as a beautiful custom fireplace and TWO covered porches. The spacious kitchen features a Whirlpool SS appliance package, cabinets with slow close doors and drawers & granite countertops. The stunning master ensuite showcases 2 large walk in closets, vanities, water closets, and custom shower with dual shower heads. 2.5 miles out of Monticello, 20 minutes to Monroe, 40 minutes to downtown Madison. Unfinished lower level will be stubbed for full bath, plenty of room for additional bedrooms, rec room or whatever you desire.Estimated completion February, 2022.

Featured Monticello Brokers