Houses for Sale

Best Deals in Old Lyme, Connecticut

Back to Best Deals

Tour these homes now!

Call 1-855-440-1362
to get connected

Photo by Ralph Kelly on Unsplash
0
 

$325,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 695

2 Joyce Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371

5.0 Bedrooms

4.0 Bathrooms

2,909 sqft

Large 2003 Cape Cod situated on 1 acre very private lot close to Roger’s Lake area where you can boat, swim, fish and more! This home has tons of living space with wide open rooms with hardwood floors, walkout dry basement with natural light, huge upper level deck that is partially covered and two car garage under. The first floor features massive great room with half bath and entry area. This room is very open to the dining room and kitchen. The first floor has a full bath and two bedrooms. The second floor needs some finishing but has three bedrooms, a laundry room, a full bath that needs a bit more tile work in the shower/tub area. There is a huge master bedroom with a walk in closet and space for a large private master bathroom and dressing room that needs to be completed. You can make it your own. The second floor also has a spacious family room! There is over 2900 square feet of living space and another few hundred square feet that could be finished in the walkout basement. In need of some finishing and updates, this home can quickly become your dream home! Call for your private showing today.

0
 

$499,900

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 335

3 Apple Tree Drive
Old Lyme, CT 06371

3.0 Bedrooms

3.0 Bathrooms

3,440 sqft

WALK TO ROGERS LAKE from this ideal location - It doesn’t get any better than this! This 3-4 bedroom colonial is sited on a cul-de-sac lot, and has been meticulously kept and updated! This is an easy decision for those looking for a turn-key home and all of the modern conveniences! New kitchen and bathrooms and an incredible main level suite with walk in closet (a dream one!!). Upgrades include refreshed floors, smart skylights with rain sensors, new main and second floor bathrooms with beautiful tile, new laundry appliances, central air, lower level walk out with media room, gas fireplace and bar area, gas fireplace living room, and generator hookups w/ generator. Move in ready with negotiable furniture. This home is perfect for summer gatherings and is landscaped for privacy. Old Lyme is two hours to NY or Boston, minutes to Hartford, and known for art history, conservation and green spaces. There are numerous hiking trails and town landings to access the various rivers, boat launches, tennis/basketball courts, playgrounds and so much more! OL pass gives you parking access to Haines Park (Rogers Lake just steps from the house), White Sands Beach, and Soundview Beach areas - The perfect home in an amazing CT Shoreline town!

0
 

$449,900

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 391

138 Four Mile River Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371

4.0 Bedrooms

4.0 Bathrooms

3,055 sqft

Amazing opportunity with this charming, updated Cape conveniently located between Boston Post Rd and I-95. The main home offers a spacious, recently updated kitchen that opens to the living room with beautiful pine floors, wood burning fireplace and a wet bar. Large windows and slider out to the back deck flood these 2 rooms with natural light. The dining room walks out to the 3 season sunroom perfect for both relaxing and entertaining, and is open to the formal siting room at the front of the house which has direct views through the sunroom. A half bath and access to the in-law complete the main level. The upper level features 3 generous sized bedrooms including the master suite with stand-up shower, jacuzzi tub, and walk-in closet with built-ins and a laundry chute. Upstairs is complete with a second full bath and brand new carpet. This home has the perfect in-law set up with a separate entrance and can access the main home through the laundry room. Or consider either of these spaces as a rental for income or to subsidize a mortgage, home office or potential business opportunity? There's an open concept with the kitchen, dining and living room with new vinyl flooring and a slider out to the back deck that wraps around the side. Upstairs is a very spacious bedroom with full bath. Completely painted inside and out, new roof, newer boiler, newer hot water storage tank, newer well pump, double pane vinyl windows, 2 car garage and U-shaped driveway all make this home a must see!

0
 

$425,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 301

144 Mile Creek Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371

4.0 Bedrooms

3.0 Bathrooms

2,818 sqft

Privacy and tranquility abound in this classic 4 bedroom, 2 1/2 bathroom colonial charmer. This home is set back from the road on over two acres of land, with a shed and barn structure, in addition to a stone pond feature. Inside you will enjoy ample cabinet space and countertops for food prep in the kitchen as well as a formal dining room for entertaining. Also included, an in-law or guest suite complete with a kitchen and separate entrance. Best of all you can go "green" and save green with eco-friendly solar panels, which have been fully paid off. Just minutes from Mile Creek Preserve, Soundview Beach, and Rocky Neck State Park, take advantage of all this home has to offer.

0
 

$310,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 202

23 Wildwood Drive
Old Lyme, CT 06371

2.0 Bedrooms

3.0 Bathrooms

1,808 sqft

Cute 2-bedroom, 2.5 bath ranch with open floor plan, hardwood floors throughout, a fireplace in the living room two tier deck. Master bedroom with a full bath, nice sized guest bedroom and an office on the main floor. The lower level has a large family room with wet bar, built-ins and slider out to the deck and private yard as well as a half bath and laundry room. This home also features a motorized chairlift, solar panels/hot water and two car garage. Located in the Oakridge Forest Beach Association with a short walk to the lake/beach. Make your move.

Tour these homes now!

Call 1-855-440-1362
to get connected

Photo by Ralph Kelly on Unsplash
0
 

$495,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 391

246 Mile Creek Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371

4.0 Bedrooms

3.0 Bathrooms

2,613 sqft

If you are ever required to stay home, this is the house to be in. A Spectacular Entrance with such warm and inviting décor. An open concept with so many private getaway niches. 2 Private terraces, opposite side of the home. A beautiful large balcony off the master bedroom sitting room, and a deck off the master bedroom facing the pool. Your guest or family members will enjoy morning coffee in their cozy guess room with a private deck. Did I mention your backyard patio and Gunite pool, for you, your family, and friends to enjoy? A fabulous kitchen open to the family room with Avonite counters, center island, plenty of cabinets, and access to the laundry room and garage. Your serene master bedroom has an en suite and an electric fireplace for those chilly nights. The spectacular main level has a open concept living room and family room with sliders that lead to separate terrace. Your dining room is meticulously placed in the center of the home in front of the sunroom's French door for easy gathering and conversation. This home has it all. In the past 5 years sellers installed a whole house on demand generator, 2 new central AC units, whole house water filtration system, new washer and dryer, refrigerator, built in oven, new light fixtures, and exterior has been painted. Last owners installed a new septic system (5-7 years old) and a new roof round about 2010. All visitors must wear a mask. Close to I 95, New York, Casinos, & Beach

0
 

$1,000,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 73

4-2 Talcott Farm Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371

4.0 Bedrooms

4.0 Bathrooms

4,339 sqft

Welcome to 4-2 Talcott Farm! This stunning custom-built home will melt your heart! As you walk into the graceful foyer you will be greeted by a curved sweeping staircase and stunning views in all directions of a flowing, sun-drenched floor plan. Continue into the gorgeous, remodeled kitchen with Viking appliances and pantry area that looks out to a view of the lovely in-ground gunite pool bordered by a wrap-around deck that perfectly complements the flow of the interior. Continue into the Great Room with vaulted ceilings, fireplace, and expansive views of the rock outcroppings and pool area. This home offers open one floor living with a paneled library/office with fireplace and master bedroom suite overlooking the pool and gardens on the main level. With its connection to its beautiful natural setting this home exudes sophistication and charm. Three large bedrooms and two baths on the second floor provide additional space. Other features are recently updated bathrooms, 3 car garage and additional room in the dry basement. Set at the end of a private road, this home offers privacy and is in a private association with tennis court and access rights to the CT River for kayaking and more. Just minutes from the Florence Griswold Museum, Lyme Art Academy, marinas, beaches, shopping, restaurants, inns, and the quaint village of Old Lyme. Only 2 hours from Boston and New York City.

0
 

$800,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 294

23 Lords Meadow Lane
Old Lyme, CT 06371

4.0 Bedrooms

4.0 Bathrooms

3,448 sqft

New construction in Old Lyme!! Custom farm style home located in beautiful Lords Meadow. Enjoy this single story Farm style home with an accommodating floor plan for any lifestyle featuring a large kitchen/dining/great room combo. There is a 685 Sq. ft bonus room on the upper level perfect for an in home office, gym, or study. This subdivision abuts the Lay-Allen Preserve with over 200 acres of hiking trails. Conveniently located near shopping, restaurants, entertainment, healthcare, beaches and golf courses. Old Lyme is midway between Boston and New York City and less than an hour to Hartford and Providence airports.

0
 

$320,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 298

5 Swan Avenue
Old Lyme, CT 06371

4.0 Bedrooms

2.0 Bathrooms

1,323 sqft

>>> Take a 3D Tour OR Enjoy a Video Walkthrough <<< RARE OPPORTUNITY - Have you been looking for an Old Lyme beach home that has larger than a postage stamp lot with limited parking? Here it is! This 2-Story 4BR, 1.5 Bath home is on an oversized lot that's NOT in the nearby flood zone PLUS it has a "Honeymoon Cottage" structure that has so much potential with Sound View beach access. The current R-10 zoning rules won't allow you to build a home this tall anymore! If you want more when sewers are installed, you may be able to preserve the non-conformity in terms of the height/coverage and build a single larger structure (with a full basement after sewers are installed) OR you can just renovate what currently exists. There is no basement as both structures are on piers with crawlspaces. The lawn area to the right of the "Honeymoon Cottage" is where the septic leaching system is located and that provides plenty of parking. Since this home has not been used by the Sellers in 10 years, the sale is "As-Is" and the power is off. The roof has architectural shingles. The condition of the plumbing is unknown. The electric heat worked fine 10 years ago. The property is referenced as 5 Swan Avenue on the Old Lyme land records (no longer 5-7 Swan Ave). Sound View Beach, America's First Public Beach, established 1892 - is a 100-foot section of public beach. Golf Carts must be registered with the Sound View Commission, Town of Old Lyme and are subject to special use regulations.

0
 

$750,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 287

148-1 Mile Creek Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371

4.0 Bedrooms

3.0 Bathrooms

2,913 sqft

Set back on a pretty country road for privacy and quiet, this pristine Colonial offers a floor plan and amenities ideal for entertaining. A chef's kitchen complete with Subzero refrigerator and gas cooktop, is well laid out for the gourmet aficionado. Streaming light and gleaming hardwood floors accent vaulted ceilings and angled spaces. Entering the home from a front French Door, surprising details, such as an "around the corner" staircase, a picture balcony into the living room, and arched entries that define public spaces punctuate the home. The lot itself is nearly two (2) acres, some cleared, some wooded with boundless opportunities -- pool, fire pit, small barn etc. Located in historic Old Lyme, all conveniences, including beaches, are minutes away.

Tour these homes now!

Call 1-855-440-1362
to get connected

Photo by Ralph Kelly on Unsplash
0
 

$775,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 107

79-2 Rowland Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371

4.0 Bedrooms

4.0 Bathrooms

2,970 sqft

Located on over five private acres, this lovely home is full of rustic charm. Enter this spacious home through the large front porch. The living room is anchored by a huge stone wood-burning fireplace and includes exposed wood beams and sliders to the large deck. With an open floor plan, the living room, dining room, and kitchen flow seamlessly, perfect for entertaining. Off the dining room, you’ll find the charming three-season sun room with views of the partially wooded yard. The kitchen also includes sliders to the deck for easy dining al fresco. There is a sizable main floor primary bedroom suite with a huge walk-in closet, perfect for one-floor living. The main floor also includes a bonus room with extra storage. Upstairs, there are three additional bedrooms and two bathrooms, one with a whirlpool tub. Outside, enjoy an entertainer’s paradise, with a large deck and a fenced-in in-ground pool and landscaped patio. The property includes an oversized two-car garage and a second outbuilding, currently set up as a home gym. For nature lovers, there’s also a vegetable garden and a pond with a lovely fountain. Enjoy this quiet, country setting, yet this charming home is located minutes to local beaches, I-95, and the best Old Lyme has to offer. Two hours to New York and Boston.

0
 

$624,900

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 274

12 Great Oak Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371

3.0 Bedrooms

3.0 Bathrooms

2,309 sqft

To be built new construction opportunity in established subdivision in Old Lyme. Large level lot, across from open space. Quality construction, generous specifications include propane warm air heat with central air, custom kitchen allowance, hardwood and tile floors throughout, open floorplan design (or bring us your plans!). Unfinished area over garage is available for future/optional finished bonus room. See attachments for plans and specs!

0
 

$1,250,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 209

2 Brighton Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371

4.0 Bedrooms

4.0 Bathrooms

4,438 sqft

Enter this stunning contemporary colonial from the welcoming front porch into the lovely two-story foyer. The main floor boasts is perfectly set up for entertaining. Centrally located, the huge chef’s kitchen is truly the heart of the home and includes top-of-the-line appliances, a large center island with a wine fridge, and a windowed breakfast nook. Accessed from both the kitchen and the living room, the brick patio offers plenty of entertaining space as well as a hot tub. The living room is anchored by a stunning stone fireplace, which is flanked on both sides by windowed doors leading to the patio and a screened in porch. There’s also a separate formal dining room and an additional bonus room, perfect for a home office. Upstairs, the primary bedroom suite includes a lovely sitting area, two walk-in closets, and a large en suite bathroom. The laundry room is conveniently located off the primary suite, with additional access from the hall. The two additional bedrooms each have en suite bathrooms. This level also includes a large family room with a gas fireplace. The lower level consists of a full basement, half of which is finished to include yet another living space, plus an exercise area and a workshop. In addition to the attached three-car garage, there is an additional one-bay outbuilding. This lovely home is conveniently located just a short distance from the beach with easy access to the best Old Lyme has to offer and only two hours to New York and Boston.

0
 

$1,550,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 80

108 Sill Lane
Old Lyme, CT 06371

4.0 Bedrooms

5.0 Bathrooms

5,283 sqft

The iconic stone mill on Sill Lane is not only a centerpiece of the town’s history and architecture, but also featured in prominent works of art. Built in the early 1800’s, the Oliver Lay House on Upper Mill Pond is often depicted in paintings found in books and museums. The mill was fully operational up until the 1950’s at which time it was converted into a private residence. This unique property situated along a tributary of the CT river was purposefully built by the damn and pond which creates a backdrop that will delight any nature lover. With over 5,000 sf of living space this home features 4 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, 4 fireplaces along with a garden level living area nestled into the banks of the waterfall. From the main entrance you are greeted by a 2 story grand foyer featuring a wrap around balcony walkway on the 2nd floor that is open to below. With 9’ ceilings throughout, the first floor features an expansive formal living room, formal dining room, ½ bathroom and kitchen with a den perfect for reading or informal dining. Upstairs you will find 4 generously sized bedrooms all with attached or private bathrooms. With it’s picturesque landscape setting and historical significance, the mill on Sill Lane is a unique offering that will not disappoint. This is a rare opportunity to own a home that is not only a nature lover’s paradise and a piece of history but also a living piece of art.

0
 

$825,000

Residential / Single Family Residence For Sale

Days on Market: 296

25 Lords Meadow Lane
Old Lyme, CT 06371

4.0 Bedrooms

3.0 Bathrooms

2,847 sqft

New construction in Lords Meadow. Rare opportunity to customize your own dream home located in a beautiful setting. This custom designed single story modern style Farm house offers an accommodating floor plan for any lifestyle. This home is designed with a front and rear porch. There is a jack and jill style bathroom connecting 2 of the bedrooms. The Lay-Allen Preserve with over 200 acres of hiking trails is steps away from this lot. Old Lyme is midway between Boston and New York City and less than an hour to Hartford and Providence International airports.

123